SC suspends RTC judge, fines her P200,000 over ‘habit’ of delay; raises bar for En Banc admin cases
The Supreme Court (SC) has suspended a Manila Regional Trial Court (RTC) judge for one year and one day without pay and fined her P200,000 after a judicial audit found that she sat on hundreds of cases, delayed arraignments and kept detainees in jail long after they had finished serving their sentences while she was still a Caloocan City trial judge.
In a decision promulgated on June 3, 2026 and penned by Associate Justice Lazaro-Javier, the SC En Banc found Judge Juliet C. Azarraga-Chanyongco, presiding judge of Branch 49, RTC Manila, liable for gross neglect of duty and gross ignorance of the law. The charges stemmed from her stint as presiding judge of Branch 53, Metropolitan Trial Court (MeTC), Caloocan City.
The Court used the same decision to amend its own Internal Rules. It raised the penalty thresholds for administrative cases against judges, court officials and personnel that must be acted on by the Court En Banc: from a suspension of more than one year to more than three years, and from a fine of more than P40,000 to more than P200,000.
The suspension took effect immediately. The judge was given three months from receipt of the decision to pay the fine, and was sternly warned that a repeat of the same or similar infractions “shall be dealt with more severely by the Court.”
Senior Associate Justice Marvic M.V.F. Leonen agreed that the judge was guilty but dissented on the penalty. He said she should have been given the maximum: a three-year suspension and a P500,000 fine.
Audit came with a promotion
The case began with a judicial audit of the Caloocan court conducted on May 23 to 25, May 30 to 31, and June 1, 2022. The Office of the Court Administrator (OCA) ordered the audit in connection with Azarraga-Chanyongco’s promotion to the Manila RTC, and to check reports it had received about irregularities and inefficiency in her sala.
The audit team found that 359 arraignments had been reset several times but never pushed through. In six sample cases, hearings were postponed because of the COVID-19 pandemic, the absence of the judge, the absence of the public prosecutor, the absence of one or both parties, or “lack of material time,” with one to three months between settings.
According to the OCA, there were hearing days when the accused may have been present and could have been arraigned. It said arraignments could have been called first on the calendar, and special counsels appointed in place of an absent prosecutor or Public Attorney’s Office (PAO) lawyer.
The auditors also found that the judge routinely set cases for “clarificatory hearing” on her own initiative even when they were ripe for decision.
In one civil case for recovery of possession, the plaintiff’s formal offer of evidence was admitted on June 30, 2018. Almost a year later, the judge set the case for clarificatory hearing, then reset it again and again until November 2021. “It is not for the judge to actively elicit evidence from any party during the so-called clarificatory hearing,” the audit team said.
In a direct assault case, a pending motion for partial reconsideration was set for clarificatory hearing and reset five times between July 2021 and February 2022. No hearing ever took place.
In an estafa case, instead of simply requiring the prosecution to submit a written formal offer of evidence, the judge set the offer itself for hearing. The setting was moved five times, and the prosecution’s submission was delayed by one year and three months.
The audit further found that she ordered the archiving of 14 cases even though the accused had already been arraigned, instead of proceeding with trial in absentia.
Jailed beyond their sentence
The most serious finding came after the audit. In a letter dated June 16, 2022, Acting Presiding Judge Concepcion Billones reported that several accused who had pleaded guilty were never released by Azarraga-Chanyongco despite having fully served their sentences.
The branch clerk of court explained that the judge used to issue a single order containing both the sentence and the order of release. She later changed this and required the jail warden to first submit a certificate of detention before she would issue a separate release order.
This made the release of the accused dependent on the police, “despite all indications on record that the accused was in fact detained.” The clerk added that some police stations charge P500 for the certificate, so if no relative came forward to pay, no certificate would be issued.
In one case, an accused sentenced to just 10 days in jail after pleading guilty on June 21, 2021 was released only on June 16, 2022, almost a year later, and only upon the order of the acting presiding judge who discovered the lapse.
‘Personal tragedy and sorrow’
In her comment, Azarraga-Chanyongco took full responsibility for her lapses. She said the pandemic and her own cancer scare took a toll on her mental and emotional state, and that she was distracted while caring for her ailing mother.
She cited the absence of prosecutors and counsels, the closure of courts during the pandemic, and flooding in her chamber, courtroom and staff office, which forced the power supply to be cut to avoid electrocution.
She defended the certificate of detention as “clear-cut proof” that an accused had served the sentence, since booking sheets and arrest reports were sometimes missing from the records, and said she acted in good faith.
She begged for compassion and forgiveness, apologized for letting her personal tragedy and sorrow affect her duties, and promised that the same mistakes would never be repeated.
‘Major culprit that erodes public faith’
The Judicial Integrity Board (JIB), in a report dated May 24, 2024, recommended fines of P150,000 each for gross ignorance of the law and gross neglect of duty. In a later report dated Nov. 4, 2025, the Judicial Integrity Office (JIO) recommended fines of P101,000 for each offense. Both recommended a stern warning.
The SC agreed with their “uniform findings” of liability but went further on the penalty.
It first held that the 2025 Code of Judicial Conduct and Accountability (CJCA), which took effect on Dec. 21, 2025, applies to the case, since the code covers all pending and future cases unless its retroactive application would not be feasible or would work injustice.
The Court said Azarraga-Chanyongco “habitually incurred delay at every stage of the proceedings before her sala,” causing “years of delayed arraignments and disposition of cases way beyond the prescribed periods under the rules.”
“Notwithstanding the reasons Judge Azarraga-Chanyongco proffers, the delays she incurred in the resolution of more than 300 cases have caused prejudice to more than 300 members of the public who had placed their trust in the justice system,” the SC said.
“As the Court has invariably pronounced, delay in the disposition of cases is a major culprit that erodes public faith and confidence in the judicial system,” it added, noting that Article VIII, Section 15(1) of the Constitution requires lower courts to resolve cases within three months.
The Court rejected her claim that she had prioritized urgent cases, pointing to her failure to issue release orders in nine criminal cases where the accused stayed in jail after fully serving their sentences.
On gross ignorance of the law, the SC said that setting arraignments and the resolution of cases beyond the prescribed periods, and archiving cases of arraigned accused instead of proceeding with trial in absentia, “clearly defeated the purpose” of the rules “to uphold the right of the accused to speedy disposition of their cases especially where the affected parties are persons deprived of liberty.”
First offense ‘only because’ of the audit
The SC then applied the heavier penalties under the CJCA. Under Rule 140 of the Rules of Court, as amended by A.M. No. 21-08-09-SC, a serious charge carried a suspension of more than six months up to one year, or a fine of more than P100,000 up to P200,000. Under Section 22, Canon VII of the CJCA, suspension now runs from one year and one day up to three years, and fines from P101,000 up to P500,000.
The Court said applying the stricter penalties does not work an injustice, since gross neglect of duty and gross ignorance of the law “have long been classified as serious charges both in the present and the old rules.” It means only that the Court “has taken on a stricter stance in ensuring that members of the bench adhere to the highest standards of professionalism,” it said.
While it was her first offense, the SC said it could not take that “in isolation and at face value.” It noted that she caused delay through at least four means: delayed arraignments, unnecessary clarificatory hearings, hearings on formal offers of evidence, and unnecessary archiving of cases.
“This, we cannot countenance,” the Court said.
“Mistakes, when repeated as many times as in this case, already take the form of a habit, nay, a bad practice that must be curbed at all costs,” it added. “To be sure, this is Judge Azarraga-Chanyongco’s first offense only because, despite her years of habitual delays, this was the first time her actions were reported and only because a judicial audit was due in light of her promotion to the RTC.”
The Court offset the mitigating circumstance of first offense against what it called the aggravating circumstance of a finding of multiple offenses. It said that, having been found guilty of two serious offenses, “nothing bars the Court from ordering her dismissal from the service and the forfeiture of her benefits.”
It chose leniency instead, citing “the many years of service” she may still render, her remorse and her potential, “with the highest hope that Judge Azarraga-Chanyongco has reflected on her mistakes and will endeavor to correct her lapses.”
Leonen: Impose the maximum
In his concurring and dissenting opinion, Leonen said the delays “were not merely inadvertent but were deliberate on her part,” pointing to the needless clarificatory hearings, the hearings on mere offers of evidence, the archiving of cases, and the added certification required before detainees could be freed.
“The delay cannot be evaluated merely by the time that has lapsed. More consequential is the effect that the delay caused the parties in each case, particularly in criminal cases where the liberty of the accused is at stake,” he wrote.
Keeping accused persons in jail after they had served their sentences, he said, “is not only a violation of rules of procedure, but a violation of the constitutional rights of the parties involved in each case affected by delay.”
Leonen cited Office of the Court Administrator v. Balo, where the Court held that “[i]f unjustified delay in even a single case within the required period may constitute gross neglect of duty, with more reason that delay in multiple cases must be considered gross neglect.” Since delay in one case already warrants a penalty for a serious offense, he argued, “it is only proper that the most severe penalty be imposed for undue delay in multiple cases.”
He acknowledged that it may be the judge’s first offense and that she had shown remorse. But he noted that under Section 25, Canon VII of the CJCA, the Court may still impose the next higher or lower penalty depending on “the number and gravity” of the circumstances present. In this case, he said, the number of cases, the habitual delay, and its gravity and consequences “far outweigh the mitigating circumstances.”
“Indubitably, this Court does not countenance actions that are far below the standards expected of members, officials, and employees of the Judiciary and, thus, should not hesitate to impose the penalties commensurate to the gravity of the transgressions committed,” Leonen said.
Fewer admin cases for the full court
In the last part of the decision, the SC said the CJCA’s expanded list of charges and higher penalties made it necessary to update the rules on how it disposes of administrative cases.
It amended Rule 2, Section 3(e) of the Internal Rules of the Supreme Court (A.M. No. 10-4-20-SC), which lists the administrative cases the Court En Banc must act on. Before the amendment, these covered cases where the penalty recommended or to be imposed is dismissal of a judge, official or court employee, disbarment of a lawyer, suspension of more than one year, or a fine exceeding P40,000.
Under the amended rule, the En Banc will act on cases involving dismissal, disbarment, suspension of more than three years, or a fine exceeding P200,000.
“An increased threshold would allow more administrative cases to be processed and resolved through streamlined procedures, thus, reducing the burden on the dockets of the Court En Banc and enabling expedited resolution for parties, especially in cases where time, resources, and procedural simplicity are critical,” the SC said.
“Surely, this is a proactive step to alleviate congestion and case backlogs, as well as promote judicial economy and better resource allocation within the Court,” it added.